Traders Face $1.4 Billion Loss on Faltering Ghana Cocoa Supply

COCOA

LONDON/ACCRA, July 15  - The cocoa market is reeling from a severe disruption as traders grapple with an unprecedented shortfall in Ghana's cocoa supply. Trading houses are staring at losses estimated to be at least $1 billion due to Ghana's inability to deliver its promised cocoa beans this year. This disruption has forced traders to liquidate short positions amidst a rallying market, exacerbating financial losses.

The Crisis Unfolded

Ghana, the world’s second-largest cocoa producer, has been hit hard by a series of unfortunate events—adverse weather conditions, diseases affecting cocoa beans, widespread smuggling, and illegal gold mining activities. These factors have significantly reduced the country's cocoa production, leading to a drastic fall in the volume of beans available for export. Consequently, global cocoa prices have soared this year, affecting the entire supply chain.

The Financial Fallout

Ghanaian authorities, who handle the sale of the country's cocoa beans, are now looking to delay the delivery of up to 350,000 metric tons of cocoa this season. This quantity represents nearly half of the beans Ghana sold, which has thrown the market into disarray. The delay is set to cause severe financial losses for traders and processors. According to sources, a delay of this magnitude means losses could amount to around $4,000 per ton on cocoa futures. With 350,000 tons delayed, the cumulative loss is projected to be approximately $1.4 billion​ (African Arbitration Association)​.

Market Reactions and Strategies

Trading houses such as Cargill, Olam, and Barry Callebaut use the futures market to hedge or lock in prices for cocoa they have yet to sell to chocolate manufacturers. The head cocoa trader at a global trading house, speaking on condition of anonymity, noted that trading in both the physical and futures cocoa markets has nearly ground to a halt due to deep losses and prevailing uncertainty.

To hedge against potential price falls, traders typically take short positions in the futures market while awaiting the physical commodity. However, when the physical delivery is delayed in a rising market, this strategy unravels, forcing traders to liquidate short positions at significant losses and establish new positions for future deliveries. For instance, traders who initially took short positions at around $3,000 per ton faced market prices of $11,000 per ton in April 2024, resulting in losses of $8,000 per ton. Even when rolling over to May 2025 futures at $7,000 per ton, they still face an aggregate loss of $4,000 per ton when the physical cocoa eventually arrives​ (African Arbitration Association)​.

Industry-Wide Implications

This disruption has far-reaching implications beyond the trading floors. Chocolate prices have surged globally, compelling manufacturers to reduce the size of their products. Firms like Hershey and Mondelez are finding it challenging to pass on these increased costs to consumers, who are already cutting back on chocolate purchases due to rising prices.

Moreover, the liquidity crunch in the market has exacerbated price volatility. Exchanges are demanding higher cash collateral, known as margin calls, from traders to cover their hedges, adding further financial strain. This requirement has reduced market liquidity, making it harder for traders to manage their positions and contributing to increased price fluctuations​ (African Arbitration Association)​.

The Road Ahead

As the cocoa market faces a third successive year of deficit, prices have roughly doubled this year. Traders and processors are scrambling to mitigate their losses, which includes charging higher prices for cocoa products like powder and butter. However, the economic burden on consumers and the overall market stability remains a significant concern.

Ghana's cocoa sector, crucial for its economy, must address these challenges through enhanced agricultural practices, stricter regulations to curb smuggling, and sustainable mining practices. International support and investments in the cocoa sector could also help stabilize the market and prevent future disruptions.

In conclusion, the unfolding situation in Ghana's cocoa market underscores the complexities and risks inherent in global commodity trading. It highlights the need for robust risk management strategies and the importance of maintaining a resilient supply chain to weather such unforeseen disruptions. As the market navigates these turbulent times, stakeholders must collaborate to ensure long-term stability and growth in the cocoa industry.

For more detailed analyses and updates on global commodity markets and investment opportunities in Africa, follow Delcare and Co.'s expert insights.